07 May 2010

Key should reprimand Smith for eavesdropping

A press release from the Labour Party by Lynne Pillay
Prime Minister John Key should reprimand ACC Minister Nick Smith for his attempts to bully sexual abuse survivor Louise Nicholas, Labour’s Victims Rights spokesperson Lynne Pillay says.
“Dr Smith today initially denied having bullied Louise Nicholas when she sought to make a time to meet with him to give him t-shirts detailing the abuse members the Courageous Women’s group had suffered and their concerns about the National Government-introduced ACC guidelines,” Lynne Pillay said.
“Bizarrely, after having denied bullying Ms Nicholas, Dr Smith then tabled an email which clearly showed that he had allowed staff members to listen in on his private conversation, and that staff members had then emailed John Key’s office about the phone call. Louise Nicholas has confirmed Dr Smith never informed her he was allowing staff members to listen in on the phone call and that she was indeed bullied.
“Why were staff members from John Key and Nick Smith’s office having email conversations about the phone call that was made to Louise Nicholas if there was no problem? It is simply unacceptable for Nick Smith to contact someone about concerns they have on sexual abuse guidelines and secretly allow other people to listen in. This is disgraceful.
“National’s guidelines on sexual abuse have resulted in a rapid increase in the number of sexual abuse survivors being denied counselling support by ACC. The Minister has consistently refused to acknowledge the problem and now he is bullying people who legitimately try and raise concerns with him.
“Labour calls on John Key to take action against Dr Smith and his unacceptable behaviour,” Lynne Pillay said.
http://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/PA1005/S00117.htm

3 comments:

  1. Dear Ms Morrison (a friend of mine)

    Thank you very much for bringing this to our attention. I received your direct email today, and David also forwarded your correspondence.

    The College has not supported the new ACC Pathway – indeed declined to release a press statement in support of this last year. The College has expressed no position on regulating counselling etc – this is an ACC initiative. Indeed psychiatrists cannot work effectively for New Zealanders MH needs without the support of, and collaboration with, our non medical psychotherapist and other colleagues. It is therefore good to be able to address the very issue you raise - that of doctors being seen to be turf protecting. Please be assured this is something we are actively not engaged in.

    There is a difference between the independently produced Massey Guidelines for the Treatment of PTSD – commissioned by ACC – and the new ACC Sensitive claims pathway. The two have become muddled I think. The Massey guidelines we have ‘supported’ as an up to date literature review of the evidence based treatments for PTSD. We are concerned by and actively advocating for better rather than more restricted access for New Zealanders to psychotherapies – whether through ACC, General Practice or DHB services.

    I have asked Audrey Holmes at the NZ Office to craft a fuller response for you, including our comments to date on the issue of diagnosis. I am very pleased you gave your time to write. We will be responding to what appears to be an inaccurate remark by the Minister in this regard.

    Yours Sincerely

    Lyndy Matthews

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for sharing that, Jax - interesting! I assume this is from the RANZ College of Psychiatrists? I'd be very interested to hear what the GPs have to say.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dear Lisa

    I know that you have already seen our media release but I am attaching it again for you to re-read. You will see that while the College has welcomed ACC using evidence-based guidelines, we make no mention of the pathway that they introduced to support the guidelines.

    The Minister of ACC referred to our media statement in the House, but any attempt to imply that our statement was anything more than the College supporting the use of an evidence-based approach is unhelpful.

    We have welcomed the Minister's recent review and we remain committed to ensuring that all patients, including those who require assistance following sexual abuse, are provided with safe, quality treatment and care that suits their specific needs.

    We will continue to work with the College of Psychiatrists and ACC on this matter.

    Yours sincerely

    Karen Thomas
    Chief Executive Officer
    Royal New Zealand College of General Practitioners
    PO Box 10 440
    Wellington 6036
    Ph 64 4 496 5990
    karen.thomas@rnzcgp.org.nz

    ReplyDelete